Adobe Exchange: Relevance Sorting Bug - Plugins Sorted by Product ID

I want to point out an issue with the Relevance sorting in Adobe Exchange. It’s been around for almost four years now and affects the visibility of both free and paid plugins.

How it works

When you open Adobe Exchange, the default sorting is Recent, which is perfectly fine.

But sometime around 2022-2023, after a marketplace update, something changed. Now, whenever you select an application like Photoshop, After Effects, Premiere Pro, or Lightroom, the sorting automatically switches from Recent to Relevance.

Before that update, the selected sorting option stayed the same when switching between applications. Now it changes automatically, and most users probably don’t even notice it.

What’s wrong with Relevance?

I checked the first 36 plugins across three pages in the Photoshop category and found that all 36 were sorted by their internal Product IDs in ascending order.

Here are the first six plugins:

  1. ToonFlow - 00178e2f

  2. Gridline - 0035b46c

  3. MesGaleries - 007f567c

  4. Relayter Asset Manager - 00e427e0

  5. CUD Accessibility Suite - 00f8282e

  6. NTB Lens - 010de8cb

The same ID ordering continues across all three pages I checked, without a single exception.

This also happens when selecting other applications. Each category has its own list:

  • Photoshop - Photoshop plugins are sorted by their Product IDs.

  • After Effects - the same thing happens with After Effects extensions.

  • Premiere Pro - its own plugins are sorted the same way.

  • Lightroom - the same behavior applies to Lightroom plugins.

So basically, Relevance filters the plugins by the selected application and then appears to sort them by their internal IDs.

This means users keep seeing almost the same plugins at the top of the listings year after year. Sometimes a new plugin appears near the top simply because it received a smaller ID.

Suggested solution

I think Relevance should simply be removed from regular marketplace browsing.

The funny thing is that Creative Cloud Desktop Marketplace doesn’t even have a Relevance sorting option.

Relevance makes sense when someone enters a search query, but I don’t see why it should activate just because a user clicks Photoshop or After Effects.

This has been happening since around 2022-2023, and nothing has changed in all that time.

Could this automatic switch to Relevance simply be removed? Selecting an application should just filter the available plugins without changing the default sorting or confusing users with an unexpected sorting option.

4 Likes